Talk:Whistles

Article title + scope
While trying to find out more about the production and release of Whistles (which is difficult due to bad archiving) I have to re-evaluate my decision to move this article.

While Hussie was initially writing and releasing it, the grouping was done as chapters without any idea of there being volumes. Now Whistles isn't the first time Hussie did something by chapters and then we grouped it by subsequent release volumes (Problem Sleuth), however Whistles and Problem Sleuth exist in quite different situations. PWhistles volume two doesn't exist, a mostly complete draft of chapter 4 exists that was supposed to be in volume two exists but that is all. I had considered making a Volume Two page, but given how little there is, not even a proper name perhaps it might be prudent to go back to just "Whistles" as despite the Problem Sleuth volume pages (and also; the Homestuck act pages) we do have articles to document the work as a whole, and given the issues I have just outlined, doing the same thing with Whistles would near make the volume pages redundant, so perhaps we should just acknowledge that and rename it back to Whistles and cover all the chapters there.

Also each chapter (from volume one) was actually published and sold as its own issue and even have their own cover pages (see image) which further muddies the issue especially in regards to Problem Sleuth where that was never a thing. - The Light6 (talk) 09:56, June 24, 2014 (UTC)